Hilltop Self Storage

2650 Carlisle Pike
New Oxford, PA 17350
(717) 883-6437

Hilltop Self Storage

2650 Carlisle Pike,
New Oxford, PA 17350
(717) 883-6437
  • Mon9:00am - 5:00pm
  • Tue9:00am - 5:00pm
  • Wed9:00am - 5:00pm
  • Thu9:00am - 5:00pm
  • Fri9:00am - 5:00pm
  • Sat8:00am - 12:00pm
  • SunClosed
  • Mon6:00am - 10:00pm
  • Tue6:00am - 10:00pm
  • Wed6:00am - 10:00pm
  • Thu6:00am - 10:00pm
  • Fri6:00am - 10:00pm
  • Sat6:00am - 10:00pm
  • Sun6:00am - 10:00pm
small unit
5' x 5' Interior Unit
    Small Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $17
Rent this unit
small unit
5' x 5' Drive Up Unit
    Small Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $19
Rent this unit
small unit
5' x 5' Climate Controlled
    Small Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $25
Rent this unit
small unit
5' x 10' Interior Unit
    Small Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $35
Rent this unit
small unit
5' x 10' Drive Up Unit
    Small Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $37
Rent this unit
small unit
5' x 10' Climate Controlled
    Small Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $69
Rent this unit
medium unit
6' x 10' Drive Up Unit
    Medium Unit

Starting at $62
Call Now
medium unit
5' x 15' Drive Up Unit
    Medium Unit

Starting at $119
Call Now
medium unit
5' x 15' Climate Controlled
    Medium Unit

Hurry, only 1 left!

Starting at $145
medium unit
7.5' x 10' Drive Up Unit
    Medium Unit

Starting at $122
Call Now
medium unit
7.5' x 10' Climate Controlled
    Medium Unit

Starting at $145
Call Now
medium unit
10' x 10' Interior Unit
    Medium Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $55
Rent this unit
medium unit
10' x 10' Drive Up Unit
    Medium Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $57
Rent this unit
medium unit
10' x 10' Climate Controlled
    Medium Unit

First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $109
Rent this unit
large unit
10' x 12' Drive Up Unit
    Large Unit

Hurry, only 3 left! First 2 Full Months 50% Off

Starting at $109
large unit
10' x 15' Drive Up Unit
    Large Unit

Hurry, only 1 left!

Starting at $120
large unit
10' x 15' Climate Controlled
    Large Unit

Hurry, only 2 left!

Starting at $225
Rent this unit
large unit
10' x 20' Drive Up Unit
    Large Unit

Hurry, only 2 left!

Starting at $139
Rent this unit
extra large unit
10' x 24' Drive Up Unit
    Extra Large Unit

Starting at $157
Call Now
extra large unit
10' x 25' Drive Up Unit
    Extra Large Unit

Hurry, only 1 left!

Starting at $256
extra large unit
10' x 30' Drive Up Unit
    Extra Large Unit

Hurry, only 1 left!

Starting at $259
extra large unit
10' x 40' Drive Up Unit
    Extra Large Unit

Hurry, only 1 left!

Starting at $334
extra large unit
20' x 20' Drive Up Unit
    Extra Large Unit

Starting at $349
Call Now
parking unit
30' Parking
    Outdoor Parking Unit

Hurry, only 1 left!

Starting at $62
parking unit
20' Parking
    Outdoor Parking Unit

Hurry, only 1 left!

Starting at $67
parking unit
40' Parking
    Outdoor Parking Unit

Starting at $105
Call Now

Didn't find your unit? Try these nearby locations

New Oxford, PA, Storage Units on Carlisle Pike

When you need more storage space in New Oxford, PA, visit Hilltop Storage on Carlisle Pike. Whether you are moving, decluttering your apartment, or growing your business, we have a storage unit for you. Use a 5’ x 5’ unit for holiday storage, or keep your entire shop’s inventory in a 10’ x 30’ unit.

No matter what unit size is right for you, we offer a wide range of inside and outside storage units and parking spaces for your convenience. Ready to create more space in New Oxford? Stop by and meet our storage professionals today! You can also rent or reserve your storage unit online, or give us a call.

Self Storage Conveniently Located Near Lincoln Highway

Whether you live near New Oxford High School or own a business by New Oxford Train Station, you deserve a self storage facility that’s close to your living space or workplace. That’s why Hilltop Self Storage is conveniently less than one mile from Lincoln Highway.

Need a moving truck or trailer for your move? The U-Haul Neighborhood Dealer is next door to us, and across the road is Kim Baker Hair Studio. In addition to the borough of New Oxford, we serve several neighboring communities, including:

  • Green Springs
  • Abbottstown
  • Bittinger
  • Edgegrove

Convenient Storage Features in New Oxford, PA

We offer a variety of storage features, including some climate controlled units. No matter your storage needs, we can help you select the right size for your needs. Explore our size guide for extra help selecting your unit. Climate control is just one of our additional features—we also offer:

  • Boat and RV parking
  • Keypad access
  • Online bill pay
  • Moving supplies available
  • Surveillance cameras

Climate Controlled Self Storage Near Green Springs

We offer a variety of storage unit options, whether you need parking storage, closest sized, or larger. Select units at our self storage facility are climate controlled. Plan to store wooden furniture, paper documents, or other temperature-sensitive items?

Climate control is ideal for belongings affected by extreme temperatures. When you choose a climate-controlled unit from Hilltop Self Storage, you can enjoy peace of mind knowing your belongings are shielded from the weather.

Rent Your Hilltop Self Storage Unit Today

When you are ready to move to your new home or need a place to store business inventory, we have a unit for you!  Our friendly staff is available to answer any questions. When you are ready to rent your New Oxford storage unit, choose your unit online today!

Features & Amenities

Every storage feature is designed from scratch against standards forged from years of experience in the self storage industry. The result is a high quality consistent customer experience you can count on.

24/7 Access
AutoPay Available
Boat and RV Parking
Climate-Control Available
Convenient Location
Drive-Up Units Available
Great Customer Service
Keypad Access
Moving Supplies Available
Online Bill Pay
Surveillance Cameras
Well-Lit Premises

What Our Customers Are Saying

I love how this place accommodate us! Everyone I spoke with was super nice and awesome! They explained everything so well and helped us so much. Highly recommen... Read More

I love how this place accommodate us! Everyone I spoke with was super nice and awesome! They explained everything so well and helped us so much. Highly recommend Hilltop storage!

Patty Ruby
February 11, 2024

They have excellent customer service and very attentive to our needs. They show that they care about their customers. We will always recommend them to anyone n... Read More

They have excellent customer service and very attentive to our needs. They show that they care about their customers. We will always recommend them to anyone needing storage.

Yolanda “yoli” Acevedo
February 04, 2024

Their online rental/reservation process is simple and well thought out. Probably took 15 minutes total to complete the rental agreement and payment process. Acc... Read More

Their online rental/reservation process is simple and well thought out. Probably took 15 minutes total to complete the rental agreement and payment process. Accessing the facility is simple using the unique code they provide for the security gate. The unit was easy to find and sized adequately for my needs. The area is clean and well lit. I received a phone call from the facilities manager to make sure everything was OK and if I had any questions or concerns...for me this is the customer service that I expect and appreciate. I highly recommend checking out Hilltop Self Storage.

William Brady
January 31, 2024

It was easy to sign up for the rental online. You have to pay additionally for the lock they give you after you reserve it. I just would say they should warn yo... Read More

It was easy to sign up for the rental online. You have to pay additionally for the lock they give you after you reserve it. I just would say they should warn you about that before confirming your rental

Emily Lovell
January 29, 2024

A Quiet and trusted place. Doreen is such a wonderful person. She is very helpful. I will miss her and Hilltop storage. I would recommend anyone to store your ... Read More

A Quiet and trusted place. Doreen is such a wonderful person. She is very helpful. I will miss her and Hilltop storage. I would recommend anyone to store your stuff or Vehicle here. Reasonable rates. And very clean.

Robin Redmond
January 12, 2024

Wonderful folks! Easy access... Amber is very helpful?? I would use Hilltop again and tell my friends about it too! Thanks guys, youre the best! HAPPY NEW YEAR!

Sho
December 29, 2023

Very friendly people in the office. Renting the space was straightforward and easy. The space was clean and ready to move into. I would definitely recommend thi... Read More

Very friendly people in the office. Renting the space was straightforward and easy. The space was clean and ready to move into. I would definitely recommend this business for your storage needs.

Laura Clegg
December 08, 2023

I stored my belongings at Hilltop for about a year. They were very attentive and helpful. I would definitely store my belongings with them again. They were also... Read More

I stored my belongings at Hilltop for about a year. They were very attentive and helpful. I would definitely store my belongings with them again. They were also very affordable.

Kayla Barrick
November 30, 2023

Completely effortless, problem free experience. Plenty of space to navigate around our 36' Class A, flat, secure. What more could you ask for? Oh, and they're s... Read More

Completely effortless, problem free experience. Plenty of space to navigate around our 36' Class A, flat, secure. What more could you ask for? Oh, and they're super nice too!

Jim Hricak
November 20, 2023

Extremely easy to get set up. The people I spoke with are friendly and knowledgeable. Only cons were the loose gravel where I parked my RV, and no veterans disc... Read More

Extremely easy to get set up. The people I spoke with are friendly and knowledgeable. Only cons were the loose gravel where I parked my RV, and no veterans discount. Would definitely do business with them again.

Sam Zito
October 28, 2023

Cheap storage unit. I got the larger size though and they left the metal divider pieces in the unit. It's not a huge deal but they do take up space. Staff is... Read More

Cheap storage unit. I got the larger size though and they left the metal divider pieces in the unit. It's not a huge deal but they do take up space. Staff is very friendly though. Would recommend

Ethan Barr
October 23, 2023

The ladies working at the office were very pleasant and friendly. I was in and out in about 20 minutes and that included looking at two storage units. Very happ... Read More

The ladies working at the office were very pleasant and friendly. I was in and out in about 20 minutes and that included looking at two storage units. Very happy with the service!

Allen Young
October 19, 2023

It was 20-30 minutes before they closed and they got my set up with a unit that night which is amazing! A lot of other places I think wouldn't even answer the p... Read More

It was 20-30 minutes before they closed and they got my set up with a unit that night which is amazing! A lot of other places I think wouldn't even answer the phone if it was that late but they did. The lady was very nice walked me through everything and helped me to the best of her ability! I give them a 10/10 for everything! Price for the unit was very cheap and it's a decent sized unit the area is very clean and tidy. I highly recommend anyone looking for a unit to contact them you won't be disappointed I promise!

Joshua Zeigler-Lyons
October 16, 2023

Hilltop self storage in new Oxford made it super easy to rent a unit. Very clean, very friendly and they were awesome to work with! Definitely would recommend H... Read More

Hilltop self storage in new Oxford made it super easy to rent a unit. Very clean, very friendly and they were awesome to work with! Definitely would recommend Hilltop Self Storage ?

Mary Dettinger
October 16, 2023

Very nice office ladies. Organized n clean throughout property. Thank u for having those carts there! Saved my back! Even had locks there (for sale, of course) ... Read More

Very nice office ladies. Organized n clean throughout property. Thank u for having those carts there! Saved my back! Even had locks there (for sale, of course) but better then getting there n not having one. Highly recommend

L S
October 02, 2023

Moving back to the area, I needed a storage unit. When I stopped at Hilltop self storage in new Oxford, they made it super easy to rent a unit. Very clean, very... Read More

Moving back to the area, I needed a storage unit. When I stopped at Hilltop self storage in new Oxford, they made it super easy to rent a unit. Very clean, very friendly and they were awesome to work with! Definitely would recommend Hilltop Self Storage ?

Mary Dettinger
September 28, 2023

Moving back to the area, I needed a storage unit. When I stopped at Hilltop self storage in new Oxford, they made it super easy to rent a unit. Very clean, very... Read More

Moving back to the area, I needed a storage unit. When I stopped at Hilltop self storage in new Oxford, they made it super easy to rent a unit. Very clean, very friendly and they were awesome to work with! Definitely would recommend Hilltop Self Storage ?

Mary Dettinger
September 22, 2023

It is great having a secure clean facility that is easy to access and secure. While the monthly rates have increased, what hasn't! Keep up the good security and... Read More

It is great having a secure clean facility that is easy to access and secure. While the monthly rates have increased, what hasn't! Keep up the good security and your great management team.

Gene Grabill
September 05, 2023

Staff very friendly and very helpful. Creating my account and renting a unit was very speedy with no problems at all. Overall they were very accommodating. Rate... Read More

Staff very friendly and very helpful. Creating my account and renting a unit was very speedy with no problems at all. Overall they were very accommodating. Rates are very reasonable. Would recommend them for anyone’s storage needs. ????

Wendy Forbes
August 29, 2023

Fantastic prices! I chose to rent the storage unit online which was incredibly convenient. The customer service is top notch

Jen
August 27, 2023

everyone here was really great and easy to work with! i was moving from florida and they were so friendly and made my experience that much better, would definit... Read More

everyone here was really great and easy to work with! i was moving from florida and they were so friendly and made my experience that much better, would definitely recommend or use again!

ashton eastwood
August 21, 2023

Staff very friendly and very helpful. Creating my account and renting a unit was very speedy with no problems at all. Overall they were very accommodating. Rate... Read More

Staff very friendly and very helpful. Creating my account and renting a unit was very speedy with no problems at all. Overall they were very accommodating. Rates are very reasonable. Would recommend them for anyone’s storage needs. ????

Wendy Forbes
July 28, 2023

Great and thorough service, friendly workers with good follow up. My only comment is that it would be nice if I could have signed up for service that started 2 ... Read More

Great and thorough service, friendly workers with good follow up. My only comment is that it would be nice if I could have signed up for service that started 2 weeks from the date I was there.

Perry Musselman
July 24, 2023

This is a clean and well maintained storage facility. Management is on hand in case there is any problems and they are courteous and friendly. I have utilized m... Read More

This is a clean and well maintained storage facility. Management is on hand in case there is any problems and they are courteous and friendly. I have utilized many self-storage facilities and this one is one of the best!

Joe
July 11, 2023

I have not had any bad issues with this story unit. Although the prices are a little ridiculous but I do understand that things keep going up in this day. And a... Read More

I have not had any bad issues with this story unit. Although the prices are a little ridiculous but I do understand that things keep going up in this day. And age, wonderful people, wonderful service.

Laurie Grimes
July 05, 2023

Staff very friendly and very helpful. Creating my account and renting a unit was very speedy with no problems at all. Overall they were very accommodating. Rate... Read More

Staff very friendly and very helpful. Creating my account and renting a unit was very speedy with no problems at all. Overall they were very accommodating. Rates are very reasonable. Would recommend them for anyone’s storage needs. ????

Wendy Forbes
June 22, 2023

This place is the cleanest storage facility I've ever used, and I've used alot. The staff is super nice too. It's so easy to start a rental, you can do it all o... Read More

This place is the cleanest storage facility I've ever used, and I've used alot. The staff is super nice too. It's so easy to start a rental, you can do it all online.

Shelley Davis
June 22, 2023

Extremely easy online process with responsive and friendly staff. Facility is extremely well maintained, easy to locate, and has great access. When I ended up h... Read More

Extremely easy online process with responsive and friendly staff. Facility is extremely well maintained, easy to locate, and has great access. When I ended up having to add a second unit 30 minutes before close they had me setup within minutes.

Anthony Russo
June 18, 2023

We had a storage unit at Hilltop for 3 months. Good experience, no issues. Also, the people that work in the office are pleasant and helpful.

Melissa Rhodes
June 05, 2023

Very nice office ladies. Organized n clean throughout property. Thank u for having those carts there! Saved my back! Even had locks there (for sale, of course) ... Read More

Very nice office ladies. Organized n clean throughout property. Thank u for having those carts there! Saved my back! Even had locks there (for sale, of course) but better then getting there n not having one. Highly recommend

L S
May 30, 2023

Excellent customer service, they are so helpful. I'm moving in a few weeks from Myrtle Beach too Pa . My biggest worry is already taken care of thanks to their ... Read More

Excellent customer service, they are so helpful. I'm moving in a few weeks from Myrtle Beach too Pa . My biggest worry is already taken care of thanks to their staff

Donna Blouse
May 27, 2023

Everyone who helped me set up my unit was wonderful. I had a lot of questions and needed to call the office many times. I was treated very kindly each time. The... Read More

Everyone who helped me set up my unit was wonderful. I had a lot of questions and needed to call the office many times. I was treated very kindly each time. They were very helpful and I will definitely refer people to their company anytime.

Janice Aileen
March 30, 2023

I’ve had a great experience so far! They’re very clear with their instructions, helpful, and the set up and move in was very simple. Great experience so far... Read More

I’ve had a great experience so far! They’re very clear with their instructions, helpful, and the set up and move in was very simple. Great experience so far!

Katelyn Melder
February 25, 2023

Amazing efficiency and the kindest staff you could ever ask for. They have awesome prices and they have great security. This is the second time I’ll be using ... Read More

Amazing efficiency and the kindest staff you could ever ask for. They have awesome prices and they have great security. This is the second time I’ll be using them for a unit and both times the process to get in and ready has been quick and simple. Very kind people 10/10 recommend!

Collin Knox
December 23, 2022

Amazing efficiency and the kindest staff you could ever ask for. They have awesome prices and they have great security. This is the second time I’ll be using ... Read More

Amazing efficiency and the kindest staff you could ever ask for. They have awesome prices and they have great security. This is the second time I’ll be using them for a unit and both times the process to get in and ready has been quick and simple. Very kind people 10/10 recommend!

Sybil Knox
December 23, 2022

I drove alittle out of my way to go here because i heard good things about them So far everything has been true. Doreen who helped me was very informative very... Read More

I drove alittle out of my way to go here because i heard good things about them So far everything has been true. Doreen who helped me was very informative very kind, was easy to talk to and she stayed to help me. I asked alot of questions they didnt mind answering. Everything was clean and affordable. Other staff was just as nice !! I highly reccomend this place!! Thanks Doreen!!

Debbie Heffner
December 09, 2022

The associate was friendly and thoroughly explained each step of the process. I felt very welcomed and comfortable through the entire experience. The facility... Read More

The associate was friendly and thoroughly explained each step of the process. I felt very welcomed and comfortable through the entire experience. The facility is safe, clean, and well lit.

Bob Glover
November 04, 2022

Amazing experience. Super nice and clean facility. Easy process. ??

Sarah Maurer
October 29, 2022

This is by far the best company to deal with for storage! They are extremely helpful, and responsive. The units are clean, well lit, and made of the best mate... Read More

This is by far the best company to deal with for storage! They are extremely helpful, and responsive. The units are clean, well lit, and made of the best materials. I expected a problem when I planned to vacate the unit, but it was all handled in minutes. It's hard to find better service!

Kevin Coutts
August 26, 2022

Clean, easy to access, could have wider driving areas but otherwise a decent place!

Ashlie Zartman
July 07, 2022

Good service, great communication, and when I no longer needed their services no BS fees tacked on. Check it out! They will help you with whatever you need.

Sid Jones
July 01, 2022

I was very impressed on how they kept you posted on the storage unit.

Travis Dull
June 13, 2022

I just checked the place out will give an update love this place they have storage for all your needs and I feel safe having my things in them. Ok they took ... Read More

I just checked the place out will give an update love this place they have storage for all your needs and I feel safe having my things in them. Ok they took care of me and do very well withe the storage units they have clean and safe.

Diana Llauget
April 03, 2022

Such awesome people here at hilltop the woman that helped me Saturday was so awesome and very informative on the contract thank you

Bradley Wade
March 14, 2022

I have delt with Doreen before about 5 years ago. She is very nice to work with. Always answers my questions. Place is always neet. It is a well kept storag... Read More

I have delt with Doreen before about 5 years ago. She is very nice to work with. Always answers my questions. Place is always neet. It is a well kept storage unit.

Linda Kroft
January 29, 2022

I had a wonderful experience storing my items with Hilltop storage facility. Staff was always pleasant and helpful and if I got locked out the gate they were pr... Read More

I had a wonderful experience storing my items with Hilltop storage facility. Staff was always pleasant and helpful and if I got locked out the gate they were prompt in getting me support and a temporary code until mine could be reset the next day. I recommend ten stars.

Anaya Smith
November 30, 2021

The issue we had has been resolved and we were taken care of. Below was previous to the resolution but I figured I would leave it here for reference of what hap... Read More

The issue we had has been resolved and we were taken care of. Below was previous to the resolution but I figured I would leave it here for reference of what happened. I am grateful that we were able to work something out and that the owners were able to help. I will continue to use Hilltop for my future storage needs and recommend them to others looking for the services they offer. We had no issues at all until somehow water got into our unit. We had insurance but they would not cover our claim because it was identified "surface water." There was some speculation of a clogged drain during a heavy rainfall in September that could've caused this. After our claim was denied I've emailed the manager in hopes that the owners would make it right. There were a couple emails back and forth but no answer on whether or not they would help us recoup our loss. I understand I signed a contract but was under the impression the insurance I bought would cover any type of water damage. It was not until after I filed my claim that I was told exactly what our insurance covered. I'm moving to the area and will vacate the unit immediately after my move. In the future I will go elsewhere for my storage needs and use this experience to ensure something like this does not happen again.

Ricky Dean
November 23, 2021

I only rented a unit for the month but the entire process from signing up to turning over was super smooth. Access is easy and the unit's door had no issues. Th... Read More

I only rented a unit for the month but the entire process from signing up to turning over was super smooth. Access is easy and the unit's door had no issues. The location is convenient and close to hanover. You can drive your car right up to the unit. In all I would consider this place again.

Scott Hummel
November 10, 2021

Accessible, friendly, professional. Units clean and dry, rates reasonable. What's not to like? We stored for 3 months or so, a 3,000 cu. ft. unit, and had one f... Read More

Accessible, friendly, professional. Units clean and dry, rates reasonable. What's not to like? We stored for 3 months or so, a 3,000 cu. ft. unit, and had one false alarm on moving out because our house deal blew up, and they pro-rated us for credit on the days we had left on our month. Altogether a top-notch outfit. And no security worries either.

Daniel Boys
October 20, 2021

Best price and availability I could find near me. Easy, convenient online process. Management is on top of things. Recommend

Tawni Prestridge
May 04, 2021